Written by Catherine Saxelby
on Thursday, 14 August 2014.
Tagged: food labels, Health Star Rating, healthy eating, label
The easy way to calculate the HSR is to use the online calculator but for those of you who want to see the workings in order to better understand this rating system, here is the explanation. Be warned – this is long and complicated. There are several steps which must be completed in sequence in order to assess a food.
All this material comes from the Health Star Rating website.To find these docs, go to the left-hand Menu and scroll down to Related Links – look for 3 pdfs/docs called Health Star Rating Style Guide, Instructions for using the Health Star Rating Calculator and the Guide to the Health Star Rating Calculator. Plus you can download an Excel file which is the Health Star Rating Calculator.
I made use of the ‘calculator’ supplied (simply an Excel file with some columns that autopopulate using a formula) to download and score a list of popular foods. So here’s what I learned along the way:
Before you start, you’ll need to know:
There are three major categories in the HSR system, with two sub-categories for Dairy (D) under each of them:
Category 1 Beverages other than dairy beverages
Category 1D Dairy beverages
Category 2 All foods other than those included in Category 1, 1D, 2D, 3 or 3D
Category 2D Dairy foods other than those included in Category 1D or 3D
Category 3 Oils and spreads (butter/margarine)
Category 3D Cheese and processed cheese (with calcium content >320 mg/100 g)
That is, is it milk, cheese or yoghurt or ‘alternative’ like soy yoghurt or rice milk AND does it have a calcium content >320 mg per 100 g OR 80 mg per 200 mL (10% of the RDI)? If so, then it classifies as a dairy food.
If it’s not dairy, then decide if your product fits in as a beverage -1D, OR anything else – 2, OR an oil/spread - 3.
HSR baseline points are calculated for the average quantity of kilojoules, saturated fat, sugars (this means natural plus added, not just sugar or honey) and sodium in 100 g or 100 ml of the food. These figures come from the nutrition information panel. Generally capped at 30 baseline points.
3A. HSR V Points may be scored for the amount of fruits, vegetables, nuts and legumes (FVNL) in a food to a maximum of 8 points. This includes fruits, vegetables, nuts including coconut, and legumes, seeds, spices, herbs, fungi and algae. Fresh, cooked, dried, frozen, canned, pickled are included as are pureed or peeled.
3B. HSR P points can be scored if your food scores less than 13 baseline points.
3C. HSR F points for fibre can be scored up to a maximum of 15 points for P and F.
Start with your total baseline points then subtract your modifying points V, P or F using the formula:
Final HSR score = Baseline points – (V points) – (P points) – (F points).
The lower the score, the better! Which is why they’ve turned it around with the Stars.
Use the table in the Guide to assign a star rating to your food depending on which of the six Categories it falls into.
The maximum is five stars with half a star in between from 0 to 5.
This scoring system is going to be used to determine if a food can make a health claim on pack. Foods with 4 or less stars are NOT eligible to make a health claim e.g. "This food is rich in calcium which builds strong bones”.
This fizzy drink already carries a Nutrition Information Panel:
Component |
Per 100mL |
Energy, kJ | 204 |
Protein, g | 0.2 |
Fat - Total, g | 0 |
Fat - Saturated, g | 0 |
Sugars, g | 11.5 |
Dietary Fibre, g | 0 |
Sodium, mg | 15 |
It’s a beverage but not from dairy so is in Category 1.
Use the table to work out the points in Column 1.
Baseline points | Energy (kJ) per 100g or 100mL | Saturated fatty acids (g) per 100g or 100mL | Total sugars (g) per 100g or 100mL | Sodium (mg) per 100g or 100mL |
0 | ≤335 | ≤1.0 | ≤5.0 | ≤90 |
1 | >334 | >1.0 | >5.0 | >90 |
2 | >670 | >2.0 | >9.0 | >180 |
3 | >1005 | >3.0 | >13.5 | >270 |
4 | >1340 | >4.0 | >18.0 | >360 |
5 | >1675 | >5.0 | >22.5 | >450 |
6 | >2010 | >6.0 | >27.0 | >540 |
7 | >2345 | >7.0 | >31.0 | >630 |
8 | >2680 | >8.0 | >36.0 | >720 |
9 | >3015 | >9.0 | >40.0 | >810 |
10 | >3350 | >10.0 | >45.0 | >900 |
I work out that this drink has:
So: Baseline points = 0 + 0 + 2 + 0 = 2
V points - This soft drink doesn’t have any fruit, vegetables, nuts or legumes. So its V points are 0.
Protein (P) points - It has 0.2 g of protein so scores zero protein points.
Fibre (F) points - Beverages (Category 1 foods) cannot score F points.
Points | Protein (g) per 100g or 100mL | Dietary Fibre (g) per 100g or 100mL |
0 | ≤1.6 | ≤0.9 |
1 | >1.6 | >0.9 |
2 | ≤3.2 | >1.9 |
3 | >4.8 | >2.8 |
4 | >6.4 | >3.7 |
5 | >8.0 | >4.7 |
The Health Stars score = 2 – 0 – 0 – 0 = 2
Health Star Rating | Food Category - 1 Non-dairy beverage | Food Category - 1D Dairy beverage | Food Category - 2* Non-dairy foods | Food Category - 2D# Dairy Foods | Food Category - 3 Oils and spreads | Food Category - 3D Cheese >320mg Calcium/100g |
5 | ≤ -6 | ≤ -1 | ≤ -11 | ≤ -2 | ≤ 13 | ≤ 22 |
4½ | -5 | -1 | -10 to -7 | -1 | 14 to 16 | 23 to 24 |
4 | -4 | 0 | -6 to -2 | 0 | 17 to 20 | 25 to 26 |
3½ | -3 | 1 | -1 to 2 | 1 | 21 to 23 | 27 to 28 |
3 | -2 | 2 | 3 to 6 | 2 | 24 to 27 | 29 to 30 |
2½ | -1 | 3 | 7 to 11 | 3 | 28 to 30 | 31 to 32 |
2 | 0 | 4 | 12 to 15 | 4 | 31 to 34 | 33 to 34 |
1½ | 1 | 5 | 16 to 20 | 6 | 35 to 37 | 35 to 36 |
1 | 2 | 6 | 21 to 24 | 6 | 38 to 41 | 37 to 39 |
½ | ≥3 | ≥7 | ≥25 | ≥7 | ≥42 | ≥39 |
*All foods other than dairy not in Category 1 or 3
# All dairy foods not in Category 1D or 3D
So for Category 1 (Non-dairy beverage), my score of 2 means the drink can carry ONE star. Pretty amazing as I thought it would get a zero! The reason why not is that we’re only calculating the Star Rating on 100 mL (less than half a glass) while in fact most people guzzle a 370 mL can - which is over three times as much.
© 2024 Foodwatch Australia. All rights reserved
Author photo by Kate Williams
Website by Joomstore eCommerce